Dominance in dogs is one of those behaviour/words that has been over-used, misused to the point that it means something entirely different to people from all different situations in life. People including Dog trainers, the postman, the guy that runs the rescue organisation, to those that work at the pound. The most common use of the “word” dominance factor is used by trainers to explain the dog’s misbehaving character, the lack of control, the failed recall or the aggressive outburst. Now behaviour is governed by the laws of learning, environment, genetics. The reason why I’m using genetics with learning is the simple. Dogs are programmed to follow, to do as they have been trained, the sit, stay, come, down, retrieve, track, is genetic, the dog’s motivation is the reward it gets at the end of it all. In the case of search and rescue dogs the reward is a game of tug of war. So these dogs must not be dominant because they listen to their handlers at all times? It has nothing to do with dominance, these dogs are well trained.
We all know by now that Canines historically were social predators, scavengers, living in packs driven by pack drive a survival mechanism, a social system of cooperation, a genetic factor that drives our dogs lives. Dogs been social predators have the ability to kill each other, but have evolved a set of behaviours ” Rules, Boundaries, Limitations” to insure they do not injure, kill each other when settling differences. These set of behaviours are Learned and kept in check by pack Rules. Dominance should be defined as: “priority access to a preferred resource”
A dominant dog is neither aggressive, nervous, anxious. ” the last two are a major contributor in a dog acting out aggressively.
A dominant dog is calm assertive, in control, everybody knows he is dominant there is a stillness of the mind about him.
As most of you know I live with a pack of 17 dogs, so I’m at the head of pack life 15hrs a day 5am start and I have the pack fed and in kennels by 8.30pm.
One thing I have learned through observation is…..
The dog who is more assertive in our social pack is usually the dog who gains more often access to a preferred resource, so would this make him more dominant over the others? What if I tell that the same dog loses interest in that resource and an other dog comes along and takes it away, has this dog lost his “dominance”? No. He simply lost interest in… say toy. The ever changing order of a pack is dynamic and highly dependent on context, dominance believe it or not is only one little aspect of our dogs behaviour not the all consuming that is often made out to be.
Two dogs live together one is more dominant over the other, this goes on for a long time, one day this more dominant dog is sick and not up to his usual self, what happens? The dog that we have perceived to be the submissive, all of a sudden is in charge running rings around the once dominant dog. The pack ranking Order is ever changing, that is why our dogs will challenge us from time to time, they sense a chance in us that we haven’t even made notice of, that is the dogs cute to make a move up the ranks, it’s not dominance it’s survival of the fittest. Have you ever heard that all puppies are born submissive? It’s true they are, so why are there different personalities in the same litter? That survival of the fittest starts at the very first breath the puppies take, Suckle or perish. the runt just does not have what it takes to fight for the best teat where the milk flows in abundance. We can call these runts genetically incompetent since the pups mind is already being modified by the uterine environment. You can read more about this in Dr Bruce Fogle’s book the dog’s mind.
Take for instance my dog Artemis, very shy compared to say Aragorn or better still Malakai
(“Malakai is what you would call a natural dominant dog and only about 2% of dogs are born this way, extremely calm, never aggressive, assertive, walks about like he is Genghis Khan.) very submissive to the pack, let’s give Artemis a lamb neck to eat….. And let’s see what Malakai will do, NOTHING! With just a persevered stare she will make him change direction and not challenge her for the prize ( sorry I have to put this in… I know what I’m doing and it’s for my learning that I do this under control constantly reading the dogs body language, dogs are predators and WILL kill each other over primal food, DON’T DO IT) once again Dominance plays no part, and Artemis will aggress towards him. Why? Aggression is just behaviour with the same rules has all other behaviours occurring only because it might be effective and efficient. Powell 1974 argues that rigid linear dominance hierarchies primarily develop under the influence of unnatural and conflictive conditions. My final thoughts on dominance…. As a matter of fact we should drop that approach completely, has it only distracts us from the vastly more straightforward approach of identifying the actual problem behaviour and the things and events in the environment that are controlling the behaviour.
-
Recent Posts
Recent Comments
DOGGY FACTS: Forms o… on Form of Aggression Mina on Tommy After two weeks at Canin… Archives
Categories
Meta